Thoughts on Communion in the Hand

From Gratia Plena:

Given the Pope’s recent Corpus Christi Mass, I’ve been thinking about communion in the hand in general, particularly its history and how it came about after VII.

The jury seems to be in agreement that the practice was introduced in modern times through disobedience.

According to Von Hildebrand, Cardinal Suenans of Belgium first introduced communion in the hand in the mid 60’s, contrary to the universal law of the Church. Other European territories quickly followed suit; and soon, Paul VI had found himself faced with a growing opposition.

In response the Pope came up with a compromise. While affirming that communion on the tongue was the norm, he permitted individual bishops’ conferences to vote on the issue. If a two-thirds majority were reached in favor of the practice, Rome would access the situation, and if the votes were approved by Rome, the bishops would be given the authority to allow communion in the hand via indult in their respective dioceses (cf., Memoriale Domini).

Pope Paul VI had hoped that by doing this, communion in the hand would be restricted to the local territories where it had been introduced illegally. However, it became apparent pretty soon that the concessions granted to a few began to spread to many. What was intended to be an exception became the norm, and interestingly enough, places where the faithful never expressed interest in the practice began to feel pressure to adopt the ‘new rite’ of communicating from their pastors.

From then on it was history. The majority of Catholics have come to accept the two methods of receiving communion as the norm. Even Pope Benedict, when formally known as Cardinal Ratzinger, had expressed his approval, he pointing out how he “wouldn’t fuss over that” since “it was done in the early Church” and “A reverent manner of receiving Communion in the hand is in itself a perfectly reasonable way to receive Communion” (The Living Liturgy: A Gift from Heaven).

Ratzinger’s words gave me pause here. It lead me to ask myself what exactly would constitute a reverent manner of receiving communion in the hand. Because lets face it, the practice in itself does not inspire reverence. If it did, Pope Paul VI would not have seen fit to point out the dangers of scandal and loss of faith associated with the practice.

Archbishop Bugnini himself recounted the Pope’s trepidation on this point. In his book “The Liturgical Reform”, he mentions how Paul VI had the greatest concern that Catholics would come to see the Eucharist as nothing more than ordinary bread, and so, he entrusted the concilium with the task of finding a solution to the problem. The bishops from all over the globe were consulted. The feedback was largely negative – the bishops clearly did not want the manner of receiving communion changed.

The bishops who did express approval, however, had reservations themselves. They proposed that along with communion in the hand, additional legislation should be put in place in order to safeguard Eucharistic reverence. Some suggested communion in the hand be forbidden to young children up to a certain age; others feared the possibility of dropping particles, and so suggested that the faithful receive through a corporal or purificator placed on the palms. Another went so far as to propose that a washbasin be made available near the sanctuary.

All these concerns had arisen because the Pope and the bishops knew well that communion in the hand was not intrinsically a sign of reverence.

So what about today? Quite a few Catholics who are deeply loyal to the Church see nothing wrong with this practice, including the current Pope. Therefore the practice of communion in the hand seems to be here for the long haul. Until this changes, perhaps a solution could be proposed to the Holy See that would incorporate a more reverential attitude? Maybe go over some of what the bishops purposed to Paul VI? One such proposition would be to require communicants to kneel when choosing to receive in the hand.

With knees bent and hands folded in a begging position, this would certainly intensify the symbolism of adoration and unworthiness befitting our Lord in the Eucharist. And with the rumors going on, it certainly appears to be a feasible solution as well. But as Msgr. Guido Marini reportedly said, “we’ll see…


2 Responses to Thoughts on Communion in the Hand

  1. Mary Smith says:

    In the beginning….hmmmmm…a bit biblical here…but

    At my First Holy Communion, we all received the Body of Christ in our mouth…

    BUT when that “changed”… I jumped at the chance to receive the Host in my hand…but of course…I wasn’t really considering that I was even receiving such a beautiful gift…
    AND then…when I began to be “enlightened” and “reawakened” to faith…I saw more people receiving the Lord on the tongue. I still had reservations…thinking that I was NOT going to make myself vulnerable or exposed with my eyes closed and my mouth agape…

    But then…How beautiful to be open, vulnerable, and exposed to the Lord????? To put aside stupid pride, to be humble before our God!!!!
    What a beautiful outward sign and inward grace!

    Thank you Fr. X for “exposing” me


  2. Becky says:

    I too have reverted to receiving our Lord on the tongue. It’s interesting the response you get and sometimes that harsh placement of the body on our tongues. I’ve even been cut on the side of the mouth when the SME shoved Him at my mouth fearfully. Our SMEs need more training as receiving on the tongue is becoming more widely respected and preferred. I like the idea of kneeling with our hands raised above our heads as beggars, which we are, or should be in front of our Lord but receiving Holy Communion for many of Catholics is just “the thing we do at Mass.” When I received my “enlightenment” Holy Mass became the most important thing I do everyday and I love Eucharistic Adoration. We need to spread the word about the gift of grace to be received in presenting ourselves to the Lord and sitting in His Holy Presence. More parishes need to embrace Eucharistic Adoration.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: